A history of A Saucerful of Secrets, assembled from release records, studio histories, archived reviews, and the evidence they leave in question.
An album made across a change of lineup
Pink Floyd’s second album includes Syd Barrett on Remember a Day, Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun and Jugband Blues. Norman Smith produced it. [1]
The seven-song program distributes its composition credits across five musicians. Roger Waters wrote three songs, Richard Wright two and Barrett one. The remaining piece, the title track, credits Waters, Wright, Nick Mason and the newly arrived David Gilmour. Gilmour and Barrett both belong to the album’s history, but their names on the personnel list do not establish that they played together on every selection. [2]
Pink Floyd’s chronology dates Gilmour’s five-piece debut to 12 January 1968 at Aston University, Birmingham. On 26 January, they played Southampton University without Barrett. Abbey Road sessions continued in February. On 1 March, they left Blackhill Enterprises for manager Steve O’Rourke of the Bryan Morrison Agency. Barrett began solo recordings at Abbey Road on 13 May 1968. [3]
In a 2016 interview, Mason described Gilmour’s arrival primarily as a source of stability. He stressed that a capable guitarist and singer had arrived, rather than an immediate replacement for Barrett as principal songwriter. Mason remembered relief at being able to perform regularly again, even while much of the repertoire still consisted of Barrett’s songs. This is his later account of the transition, rather than a statement of what every member felt at the time. [4]
Studios, producer and changing performers
The sessions connect EMI Studios at Abbey Road with De Lane Lea Studios. The recording-credit reference lists Peter Bown as engineer throughout the seven tracks. Its specific De Lane Lea associations include Remember a Day and Jugband Blues. Smith’s producer credit and Bown’s engineering credit describe different responsibilities; they are not interchangeable job titles. [5]
Smith also appears on the other side of the control-room glass. The band’s official studio-musician index credits him with drums on Remember a Day. The same index names the Stanley Myers Orchestra for brass on Corporal Clegg. This is an ensemble credit: the index does not supply the individual players or say that Myers himself conducted them. These additions mean that the record’s personnel extend beyond either version of Pink Floyd’s own lineup. [6]
Side one: four songs and four different vocal arrangements
Let There Be More Light opens with Waters’s bass figure and a science-fiction narrative centered on the arrival of a spacecraft at RAF Mildenhall. Wright sings the verses, Gilmour the choruses, and Waters supplies whispered vocals. Its allusions include Hereward the Wake and Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds. That Beatles connection is a reference in the writing, not a sampled Beatles performance. The song’s guitar feature also introduces Gilmour as a lead instrumental voice on the album. Tower later paired an edited mono version with Remember a Day for an American single; that shorter version should not be confused with the opening album track. [7]
Remember a Day was written and sung by Wright. Its account of childhood recollection is accompanied by his keyboards, Waters’s bass and Barrett’s acoustic and slide guitar. The song reference quotes Mason’s memoir acknowledging that he could not obtain the drum feel the piece needed and yielded the part to Smith, who also supplies backing vocals. It also quotes Barrett identifying his contribution as the Wright song with steel guitar, while explicitly denying that he played on Corporal Clegg. This combination of accounts is more specific than simply assigning the band’s regular drummer and incoming guitarist to the whole LP. [8]
Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun is a Waters composition with his lead vocal. Its recording began while Barrett was still in the group and received further work after Gilmour arrived. Both guitarists are credited on the recording, alongside Waters, Wright and Mason: a particular five-person performance, not evidence of a five-piece lineup for every session. Mason plays with mallets, while Wright contributes organ and vibraphone. The lyric’s literary sources include Chinese poems encountered in A. C. Graham’s Poems of the Late T’ang. The song reference associates passages with Li He and Li Shangyin. Those literary connections are distinct from the formal composition credit, which remains Waters’s. [9]
The group continued performing Set the Controls in concert, and it appears in substantially developed live versions on Ummagumma and in the Pompeii film. Those performances share the composition but are separate recordings. [9]
Corporal Clegg closes the side with another Waters song, this time about a soldier who has lost a leg in the Second World War. Gilmour, Mason and Wright share its lead vocals; Waters plays bass and contributes backing vocals. Gilmour also plays kazoo, and Smith has a spoken contribution. The military subject anticipates a recurring concern in Waters’s writing, although the performance uses comic and satirical elements. The song’s later filmed appearances require care: the Belgian television film uses a work-in-progress version with a different ending, rather than proving that the released album master was already complete at filming. [10]
The title piece: a graphic plan becomes a recording
A Saucerful of Secrets occupies almost twelve minutes at the start of side two. Its four-person writing credit is Gilmour’s first with Pink Floyd. Early labels misspell his surname as Gilmore. The recording reference describes the piece being made in separate sections during April, with mixing extending into May. Later presentations, especially on Ummagumma, name four sections: Something Else, Syncopated Pandemonium, Storm Signal and Celestial Voices. Those section names do not turn the original album’s single title-track entry into four separately released songs. [11]
Mason told Tape Op that the musicians drew a graphic representation of the music instead of using conventional notation. He remembered a plan loosely related to a classical work in three movements, each developed separately before assembly. The central section used a drum pattern that was doubled and looped. Mason could recall the construction method without remembering why that particular pattern had been chosen. He also described discovering the opening cymbal sound by placing a microphone extremely close to its edge. Changes in volume and texture were part of the design, rather than the group playing at maximum intensity throughout. The Hammond-organ finale supplied the concluding section. [12]
Other details in the recording history include backward cymbals, manipulated voices and Gilmour moving a microphone-stand leg along his guitar fretboard. Wright’s Hammond organ anchors the closing movement. The piece became a concert fixture through the early 1970s, having first appeared under the name The Massed Gadgets of Hercules. The studio version, Ummagumma performance and Pompeii film consequently document different stages of the same composition’s development. [11]
Wright’s second song and Barrett’s closing contribution
See-Saw is Wright’s second sole composition on the album and again features his lead singing. The arrangement gives him several keyboard colors: piano, Farfisa organ, Mellotron and xylophone. Gilmour plays guitar, Waters bass and Mason drums and percussion; Smith contributes backing vocals. The track’s instrumentation makes Wright’s role more substantial than a generic organ credit would suggest. It is a separate recording from Remember a Day, despite their common writer and singer: Gilmour replaces Barrett in its guitar personnel, and Mason is the drummer. The session reference places its initial work in January 1968 at EMI. [13]
Jugband Blues closes the record and is its only Barrett composition. Barrett sings and plays guitar, with Waters on bass, Wright on Farfisa and tin whistle, and Mason on drums, castanets and kazoo. Salvation Army musicians provide brass. The personnel list names Ray Bowes and Terry Camsey on cornets, Mac Carter and Ian Hankey on trombones, Les Condon on E-flat bass, Maurice Cooper on euphonium and George Whittingham on B-flat bass, alongside an unnamed additional player. Its succession of different meters is part of the recorded arrangement. [14]
Smith’s later interview account, discussed in the linked feature, attributes the initial idea for a brass ensemble to him and the suggestion of Salvation Army players to Barrett. Smith recalled the difficulty of obtaining instructions from Barrett and preparing an arrangement himself. The account also exposes a limit of retrospective testimony: Smith remembered roughly twelve to fourteen players, while the credited list is smaller. The article cites researcher David Parker’s view that musicians were working individually rather than the complete International Staff Band attending as an ensemble. The brass contribution is established more securely than a precise reconstruction of every exchange in the room. [15]
Mason later remembered the brass as a particularly affecting element of the song. His interview interpretation treats it as Barrett’s farewell, but that is a participant’s retrospective reading of the recording, not a clinical explanation of its author. [4]
Hipgnosis enters the album’s story
Hipgnosis, the partnership of Storm Thorgerson and Aubrey Powell, designed the sleeve. In the V&A’s account, Powell recalls that the musicians wanted to avoid a conventional band portrait, while EMI still wanted their faces visible. A small infrared photograph taken on Hampstead Heath became part of a hand-colored collage. Its imagery drew on comics, alchemy, astrology and flying saucers. [16]
The official chronology identifies Thorgerson and Powell as friends of the musicians and records a payment of £110 for the design. The release appeared on 28 June, followed by Pink Floyd’s appearance at the free Hyde Park concert the next day. [3]
British editions, American release and chart history
The British mono issue is Columbia SX 6258; its stereo counterpart is SCX 6258. Fitch’s edition catalog records an early label error that substituted Me for Be in Let There Be More Light, as well as the Gilmore spelling. Those printing variants belong to release history, not to different song or musician identities. [17]
The American Tower release, ST 5131, followed on 27 July 1968 in Fitch’s discography. Its cover and labels likewise use Gilmore. Unlike the radically shortened American Piper program, Saucerful retains the seven-song album sequence. The American issue is still a separate territorial release, rather than the British Columbia pressing with a different distributor. [18]
Official Charts lists the original run under Saucerful of Secrets, omitting the opening A. That Columbia entry records a peak of number nine and eleven weeks on the British album chart in 1968. Its week-ending record places the peak on 17 August. [19]
The site also has an A Saucerful of Secrets entry for later issues, with a 2019 album-chart peak of forty-six. These are different chart records for the same album’s release history; the later entry does not overturn the original top-ten result. [20]
Contemporary praise, contemporary rejection and later reassessment
Disc and Music Echo’s 10 August 1968 review rejected the idea that Barrett’s departure had ended Pink Floyd’s prospects. It welcomed Gilmour and, more strongly, praised the development of the group as a whole. The reviewer regarded the title piece alone as sufficient reason to buy the album and situated the musicians among the leading experimental rock groups. That enthusiastic contemporary response is quite different from the verdict that followed in Rolling Stone. [21]
Jim Miller’s review, published by Rolling Stone on 26 October 1968 and later republished by its Italian edition, found the second album disappointing beside Piper. He criticized Waters’s songs as dull and overextended, regarded the instrumental playing and production as diminished, and heard Corporal Clegg as excessively dependent on the Beatles’ example. He also rejected the title track’s experiments as effects insufficiently supported by musical development. These are Miller’s judgments, including his dissatisfaction with the organ-and-choral conclusion, rather than statements of consensus or technical failures established by session documentation. [22]
Richie Unterberger’s retrospective AllMusic review describes a transitional record. He emphasizes the movement from Barrett’s concise songs toward longer instrumental structures, while finding that some of the earlier atmosphere remained. Remember a Day and See-Saw are his highlights. He identifies the repeating patterns of Set the Controls, Let There Be More Light and the title piece as directions that the next records would develop. This assessment gives Wright’s songs a prominent place rather than reducing the album to the departure of one guitarist and arrival of another. [23]
The original mix and the music’s later life
On 13 April 2019, a Record Store Day edition returned the album’s original mono mix to vinyl. James Guthrie, Joel Plante and Bernie Grundman are credited with that remastering. Their work belongs to the later edition; Smith remains the original producer. Five days later, Waters joined Mason’s Saucerful of Secrets group at New York’s Beacon Theatre to sing and play gong on Set the Controls. The official chronology records both events, linking renewed attention to the original mix with continuing live reinterpretation of the repertoire. [24]
Tracks & writing credits
Writing credits describe published attribution; they do not imply equal contributions.
Side one
- Let There Be More LightRoger Waters
- Remember a DayRichard Wright
- Set the Controls for the Heart of the SunRoger Waters
- Corporal CleggRoger Waters
Side two
- A Saucerful of SecretsRoger Waters, Richard Wright, Nick Mason and David Gilmour
- See-SawRichard Wright
- Jugband BluesSyd Barrett
Read the critics
Pink Floyd explore the astral plane
Disc and Music Echo. Indexed OCR of the contemporary review inspected; direct PDF retrieval returned 403. Adjacent-column text is interleaved. Only unambiguous paragraphs naming Pink Floyd, Gilmour and the title piece are summarized; no author is guessed.
[21]Jim Miller’s 1968 A Saucerful of Secrets review
Rolling Stone / Rolling Stone Italia. Publisher-hosted Italian republication inspected and summarized in English. The original English archive returned a payment requirement. Critical judgments are attributed, and the review’s mistaken Piper writing-count statement is not adopted.
[22]A Saucerful of Secrets — review
Richie Unterberger / AllMusic. Editorial review inspected through full indexed text after direct retrieval returned 403. User reviews beneath it are not conflated with Unterberger’s assessment. No score is inferred from missing rating graphics.
[23]Questions in the record
28 or 29 June?
Pink Floyd’s chronology gives 28 June 1968. Fitch’s original British mono entry gives 29 June. The article follows the official date while retaining the alternative; the pressing description alone does not resolve the one-day difference. [3] [17]
When did recording end?
The official album overview ends its recording span in April 1968. The official timeline lists further Saucerful sessions on 27 May. Those summaries do not establish which activities or masters each cutoff includes. [1] [3]
Who drums on Remember a Day?
MusicBrainz lists both Mason and Smith on drums. The official musician index names Smith, and Mason’s memoir, quoted in the song reference, describes relinquishing the part. Linergraph therefore credits Smith without adding an unsupported second drummer. [5] [6] [8]
How many brass players recorded Jugband Blues?
The song reference names seven musicians and an eighth unnamed player. The discussion of Smith’s interview reports his larger recollected headcount. The graph preserves the named credits without inventing identities to reconcile the totals. [14] [15]
References & further reading
- A Saucerful of SecretsPink Floyd / Sony Music · Consulted 2026-11-15
June 1968 release, Smith production and Barrett’s three contributions. Official catalog distinguishes the transitional lineup from an entirely post-Barrett record.
- A Saucerful of SecretsWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Album writing credits, lineup transition and artwork. Secondary reference inspected. The encyclopedia and the official history describe differing session-date spans; do not treat a composite album lineup as the personnel on every recording.
- Pink Floyd — 1968 timelinePink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15
January lineup changes; February and May recording; June release and Hyde Park. Official retrospective chronology. The 27 May session entry conflicts with the April cutoff in the official album overview; neither is silently rewritten.
- Nick Mason discusses Pink Floyd’s early yearsUltimate Classic Rock · Consulted 2026-11-15
2016 interview: Gilmour’s arrival, Jugband Blues and the shift toward albums. Participant recollection, not a contemporaneous session log. The syndicated Moose Radio version is the same interview, not an independent source or another prose allowance.
- A Saucerful of Secrets — Discovery edition recording relationshipsMusicBrainz · Consulted 2026-11-15
Track-level engineering, original performers and seven-work sequence. Community-maintained 2011 edition metadata, used for corroborating recording credits rather than original packaging. Its extra Mason drum credit on Remember a Day is disputed below. Dates and phonographic-copyright fields are not adopted wholesale.
- Pink Floyd — studio musiciansPink Floyd / Sony Music · Consulted 2026-11-15
Norman Smith on Remember a Day; Stanley Myers Orchestra on Corporal Clegg. Official contributor index inspected. The orchestra credit is explicitly present; it does not identify individual brass players or establish that Myers personally conducted the session.
- Let There Be More LightWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Remember a DayWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Set the Controls for the Heart of the SunWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Corporal CleggWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- A Saucerful of Secrets — instrumentalWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Nick Mason: Behind the Scenes with Pink Floyd drummerJeff Touzeau / Tape Op · Consulted 2026-11-15
Issue 51, January/February 2006: graphic plan, three sections, loop and cymbal microphone. Public opening of the interview inspected. The subscription-only continuation was not accessed. Mason explicitly distinguishes his own recollection from a definitive collective history.
- See-SawWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Jugband BluesWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, recording history and track-specific personnel. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and original session paperwork were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced. Track-page release dates do not override the album chronology.
- Norman Smith’s Jugband Blues recollectionThe Holy Church of Iggy the Inuit · Consulted 2026-11-15
24 October 2014: account of Smith’s interview in the Meddle Under Review DVD featurette. Secondary discussion of a participant interview. Smith’s recollected headcount differs from the credited list. The blogger’s speculation about motives and diagnoses is not adopted.
- The graphic identity of Pink FloydVictoria and Albert Museum · Consulted 2026-11-15
Piper sleeve/date; Powell’s account of the Saucerful photograph and collage. Institutional artwork history with participant recollections. Its Piper date conflicts with the official timeline and Paule’s investigation; the disagreement remains visible. Reuse this source across albums rather than creating duplicate URL records.
- Pink Floyd — British LP editionsVernon Fitch / Pink Floyd Archives · Consulted 2026-11-15
Piper SX/SCX 6157 and Saucerful SX/SCX 6258 original entries. Edition catalog inspected through indexed text after direct retrieval timed out. Its Piper format dates differ, and its Saucerful mono entry gives 29 June versus the official chronology’s 28 June. The dates are not silently reconciled; printing variants remain edition details.
- The original Tower editions of Pink FloydVernon Fitch / Pink Floyd Archives · Consulted 2026-11-15
Piper T/ST 5093 nine-song program; original Saucerful ST 5131 entry. Specialist edition catalog inspected through indexed text. Piper’s mono and stereo releases and Saucerful’s later seven-song US release are distinct editions. Later entries on the page are not evidence for the first pressing.
- Saucerful of Secrets — original UK chart runOfficial Charts · Consulted 2026-11-15
Columbia SCX6258 entry: peak nine and eleven weeks in 1968. This entry omits the initial A in the title. A separate entry with A describes later reissues and must not replace the original chart history. Historical week-ending dates differ from the dated weekly chart display.
- A Saucerful of Secrets — later UK chart entryOfficial Charts · Consulted 2026-11-15
Rhino entry: 2019 album-chart peak 46. A later-release chart record, not evidence that the original 1968 album peaked at 46.
- Pink Floyd explore the astral planeDisc and Music Echo · Consulted 2026-11-15
10 August 1968: album review under the Pink Floyd heading. Indexed OCR of the contemporary review inspected; direct PDF retrieval returned 403. Adjacent-column text is interleaved. Only unambiguous paragraphs naming Pink Floyd, Gilmour and the title piece are summarized; no author is guessed.
- Jim Miller’s 1968 A Saucerful of Secrets reviewRolling Stone / Rolling Stone Italia · Consulted 2026-11-15
26 October 1968 review, republished in Italian on 28 June 2020. Publisher-hosted Italian republication inspected and summarized in English. The original English archive returned a payment requirement. Critical judgments are attributed, and the review’s mistaken Piper writing-count statement is not adopted.
- A Saucerful of Secrets — reviewRichie Unterberger / AllMusic · Consulted 2026-11-15
Editorial review distinguishing the shorter songs and extended pieces. Editorial review inspected through full indexed text after direct retrieval returned 403. User reviews beneath it are not conflated with Unterberger’s assessment. No score is inferred from missing rating graphics.
- Pink Floyd — 2019 timelinePink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15
13 April mono remaster; 18 April Waters appearance with Mason. Official chronology distinguishes the original 1968 mono mix from 2019 remastering. Later live performances do not replace studio recording identities.
Additional reading
Nick Mason on the title piece’s construction
The public opening of the 2006 interview discusses its diagram, loop and microphone placement.
The graphic identity of Pink Floyd
The V&A’s account includes Aubrey Powell’s sleeve-design recollections.
Jim Miller’s original English review archive
26 October 1968. Access may require a subscription; the summary above uses the publisher’s accessible Italian republication.
BBC Music — Daryl Easlea’s review
Additional critical reading. This page could not be retrieved during this research and is not used to support the narrative.