LinergraphResearch preview
← Album histories
THE ALBUM · RECORDING HISTORY

With the Beatles

The Beatles · 1963

Fourteen tracks recorded between engagements: Harrison’s first LP composition, Motown connections, a new cover portrait and Britain’s second Beatles album.

2,141 words · 31 sources · Updated 2026-11-16 · Revision 7
WITH
THE
BEATLES
’63

A history of With the Beatles, assembled from release records, studio histories, archived reviews, and the evidence they leave in question.

A second album during a changing year

Parlophone released With the Beatles on 22 November 1963, eight months after Please Please Me. Its fourteen tracks again combined original compositions with outside material. This time George Harrison contributed a song of his own. [1]

Recording fitted around concerts, broadcasting, television and the group’s first international tour to Sweden. The official history places the sessions within the period of the London Palladium appearance and Royal Variety Performance. The group was also preparing new singles, but none of this album’s tracks was issued as an original British single. The album developed across separate studio visits rather than one principal recording day. [2]

Tony Barrow’s original sleeve notes openly presented a familiar program: eight group-written songs and six selections from admired American performers. The eight originals were not all by the same writing team. Seven carried the Lennon–McCartney partnership credit, while Don’t Bother Me belonged to Harrison. Barrow also told listeners who sang individual songs and identified instrumental contributions, treating the cover repertoire as something worth naming and explaining. [3]

The sessions and the sound on tape

Work began on 18 July 1963 in Studio Two at EMI Studios. George Martin produced and Norman Smith engineered. The first session concentrated entirely on covers: You Really Got a Hold on Me, Money, Devil in Her Heart and Till There Was You. The Beatles Bible records a session lasting just under four hours, including complete performances, shorter edit pieces and additional parts. The opening day was not a run-through of the eventual album sequence. [4]

You Really Got a Hold on Me was attempted first. Seven takes were followed by short edit pieces; Martin contributed piano. Devil in Her Heart received additional parts including maracas played by Ringo Starr. An initial attempt at Till There Was You remained unsatisfactory, and the group returned to that song on 30 July. These separate stages distinguish the first session from an assumption that every song attempted that evening was already finished. [4]

Abbey Road’s account of its BTR machines describes Smith placing most instruments on one track and voices on the other for the first two Beatles albums. The studio made both mono and stereo mixes, using a BTR 2 for the mono version and a BTR 3 for stereo. Two recorded tracks did not mean just two musicians or two individual sounds: several performers could already be combined on a track. Recording format and the later stereo presentation are different parts of the production history. [5]

The work extended into the autumn. I Wanna Be Your Man began on 11 September and received further attention on four later dates. The Beatles Bible places Martin’s organ overdub on 30 September, Starr’s maracas on 3 October and a final tambourine addition on 23 October. Its account illustrates the difference between a relatively direct song and the number of studio visits needed to complete the released recording. [6]

Side one: original songs and a stage standard

It Won’t Be Long opens the album. The official song page dates its recording to 30 July and identifies it as the first original composition recorded for this project. It attributes the main composition to Lennon, with McCartney assisting on lyrics and arrangement, while retaining the shared writing credit. It was therefore neither the first song recorded for the album nor a jointly credited song whose contributions must be presumed equal. [7]

All I’ve Got to Do follows. Its official entry identifies Lennon as writer under the joint credit and places the session on 11 September. The recording subsequently appeared on Meet the Beatles! in the United States. The song remained an album track in the original British program, rather than being one of the hit singles that accompanied the group’s rise during 1963. [8]

All My Loving was recorded on 30 July. The official entry attributes the song to McCartney and documents its later life as an EP title and a Canadian single. It was not originally a British or American single, although Canadian imports entered the American chart. Its commercial history shows why the statement that the album contained no British singles cannot be extended automatically to every territory and format. [9]

McCartney recalled writing the words before the music, an unusual order for him. In the account reproduced by the Beatles Bible, he began on a tour bus and worked out the tune on a backstage piano after arriving at the venue. Lennon later praised the song while also drawing attention to his own guitar accompaniment. The performance credits identify McCartney singing, Lennon on rhythm guitar, Harrison on lead guitar and Starr on drums. [10]

Don’t Bother Me was the first Harrison-written song to appear on a Beatles album. The official recording dates are 11–12 September. Harrison remembered composing it while ill in a Bournemouth hotel during the summer engagement, treating it as a test of whether he could write a song. His later assessment was modest: the attempt encouraged him to keep writing rather than convincing him that he had already produced a major work. [11] [12]

The Beatles Bible’s personnel account gives Harrison the lead vocal and guitar, Lennon rhythm guitar and tambourine, McCartney bass and woodblock, and Starr drums and bongos. Barrow’s original sleeve instead calls McCartney’s percussion claves. The discrepancy is retained as an instrument-identification question; both sources describe percussion beyond the normal guitar, bass and drum setup, but they do not supply identical terminology. [12] [3]

Little Child carries the Lennon–McCartney credit. The official entry lists work on 11–12 September and 3 October and states that the song had been intended for Starr before I Wanna Be Your Man became his album feature. Its account retains a legacy citation warning. The stated intention to give a song to one singer is separate from the vocal heard on the completed record. [13]

Till There Was You came from Meredith Willson’s 1957 musical The Music Man and also appeared in the 1962 film. The official song history traces a much wider life through stage, film and recorded versions. McCartney’s route to the song, however, was through Peggy Lee. In his later account he recalled hearing her records through a cousin and only subsequently learning the song’s musical-theatre origin. [14] [15]

For the Beatles recording, McCartney sang and played bass, Lennon and Harrison used acoustic guitars, and Starr played bongos. The Beatles Bible lists sessions on 18 and 30 July. The song had also been included in their Decca audition and live repertoire. The arrangement on the album thus drew on a piece they could perform in several settings, not a standard newly discovered solely to fill a studio session. [15]

Please Mister Postman ends side one. The official reference gives five writers: Georgia Dobbins, William Garrett, Freddie Gorman, Brian Holland and Robert Bateman. The Marvelettes’ original was a Tamla single recorded at Hitsville U.S.A.; its studio, label and production fields belong to that earlier performance. Barrow’s sleeve notes identify Lennon’s double-tracked vocal on the Beatles version, supported by Harrison and McCartney. [16] [3]

Side two: Berry, Robinson and the album’s final songs

Roll Over Beethoven starts the second side and carries Chuck Berry’s sole writing credit. Berry’s record had appeared on Chess in 1956. Harrison sings the Beatles version, recorded on 30 July 1963. The Beatles Bible traces a change in their stage performances: Lennon had originally sung the song, with Harrison taking over in 1961. On this LP it was one of Harrison’s three vocal features, alongside Don’t Bother Me and Devil in Her Heart. [17] [18]

Hold Me Tight connects the second album to the first album’s unfinished business. It had been attempted during the Please Please Me session but left off that record. The official entry dates the new recording to 12 September. The composition survived; the issued performance was newly recorded. That distinction prevents an unused February attempt from being mistaken for the September recording simply because both have the same title and writers. [19]

You Really Got a Hold on Me is a Smokey Robinson composition associated with the Miracles’ 1962 record. The Beatles version changes the title slightly from You’ve Really Got a Hold on Me. Lennon sings with close support from Harrison and further vocals from McCartney; Martin plays piano. The Beatles Bible identifies the song as the first recorded for the new LP, and describes imported American records as a route through which the group encountered it. [20]

I Wanna Be Your Man supplies Starr’s lead-vocal feature. Lennon and McCartney also offered the song to the Rolling Stones, whose separate recording appeared as their second single in 1963. McCartney later recalled proposing a song already intended for Starr. The two bands’ releases share the composition; they are not the same recording, and the Lennon–McCartney credit on a Stones record does not mean the Beatles performed on that version. [6]

Devil in Her Heart came from the Donays’ Devil in His Heart, written by Richard Drapkin. Harrison sings the Beatles version. In his recollection reproduced by the Beatles Bible, the group found records such as this and Money while browsing the stock at Brian Epstein’s NEMS shop. The store’s wide selection exposed them to titles that had not necessarily become major British hits. A changed pronoun in the title did not turn the adaptation into a new Beatles-written composition. [21] [22]

Not a Second Time is a Lennon composition under the shared credit, recorded on 11 September. The official entry preserves his later description of attempting something in Smokey Robinson’s manner. Robinson consequently figures in this album both as the named writer of a cover and as an influence Lennon acknowledged when discussing an original. Those are distinct kinds of relationship: one is a formal composition credit, the other an attributed recollection. [23]

Money (That’s What I Want) closes the album. Its credited writers are Janie Bradford and Berry Gordy, and Barrett Strong recorded the earlier version in 1959. Lennon sings the Beatles recording, supported by McCartney and Harrison, with Starr on drums and Martin at the piano. The Beatles Bible lists work in July and September. The ending returns the album to American rhythm-and-blues repertoire after several of the group’s own songs. [24]

Robert Freeman’s half-shadow portrait

Robert Freeman supplied the cover photograph. Apple’s later tribute identifies With the Beatles as the beginning of a sequence of Freeman covers that also included A Hard Day’s Night, Beatles for Sale, Help! and Rubber Soul. The portrait’s use on the American Meet the Beatles! linked the two differently programmed albums visually, even though their titles and track selections were not identical. [25] [26]

In his 2019 tribute, McCartney challenged the assumption that the photograph had required an elaborate studio setup. He remembered Freeman working quickly in a hotel corridor, using natural light from windows at the end, and estimated that the session lasted no more than half an hour. That is a participant’s later recollection, not a timed production log. It describes how the contrasting light on the faces could result from a simple location arrangement. [26]

The British LP and the American rearrangement

Official Charts gives With the Beatles twenty-one weeks at number one. Its first chart appearance was in the week dated 30 November, at number two; it reached the top in the chart dated 7 December. A release date, first chart week and first number-one week therefore describe three different events. The album succeeded Please Please Me at the top of the British chart. [27] [2]

Capitol’s Meet the Beatles! appeared in the United States on 20 January 1964. It combined nine With the Beatles tracks with I Want to Hold Your Hand, This Boy and I Saw Her Standing There. The last of those had come from the British debut. The American package therefore crossed British album and single boundaries, and retained only one of the six covers from With the Beatles: Till There Was You. [28]

The official album overview dates the American issue of With the Beatles itself to 1987. That later issue used the British program; Meet the Beatles! remains a distinct selection despite the shared portrait. [2] [28]

Contemporary musical analysis and a later reassessment

William Mann’s Times article of 27 December 1963 considered Lennon and McCartney as composers, separately from the public spectacle of Beatlemania. He discussed harmony, melody and rhythmic interest, drawing examples from both this album and other records. His account singled out Not a Second Time and compared its closing harmonic movement with Mahler. This was contemporary musical criticism, although not a conventional track-by-track review confined to With the Beatles. [29]

Mann’s technical vocabulary became part of the song’s reception history. His analysis is an account of what a critic heard in the music; it does not by itself demonstrate that Lennon deliberately composed with Mahler in mind. Lennon’s own later reference was to Smokey Robinson. Keeping the critic’s interpretation beside the songwriter’s account allows both to be read without converting a comparison into a documented source of inspiration. [29] [23]

In Pitchfork’s 2009 review, Tom Ewing judged the sequel less successful than the debut but argued that its familiar formula still offered listeners substance. He valued the clearer studio construction, the breadth of the covers and Barrow’s informative sleeve notes. His assessment treats the album as both a rapid response to demand and a generous presentation of the group’s musical interests. [30]

Tracks & writing credits

Writing credits describe published attribution; they do not imply equal contributions.

Side one

  1. It Won’t Be LongLennon–McCartney
  2. All I’ve Got to DoLennon–McCartney
  3. All My LovingLennon–McCartney
  4. Don’t Bother MeGeorge Harrison
  5. Little ChildLennon–McCartney
  6. Till There Was YouMeredith Willson
  7. Please Mister PostmanGeorgia Dobbins–William Garrett–Freddie Gorman–Brian Holland–Robert Bateman

Read the critics

Questions in the record

Edition metadata

When did the original stereo edition appear?

The album overview gives 22 November. Some official song entries separately list 30 November for stereo. This page anchors the original mono issue; a stereo-edition date is not asserted as settled. [2] [8] [13]

Our treatmentNot reconciled
Instrument credit

Claves or woodblock on Don’t Bother Me?

Barrow’s reproduced sleeve notes say claves; the Beatles Bible personnel entry says woodblock. No instrument-specific graph assertion is selected for this disputed detail. [3] [12]

Our treatmentSources differ
Critical interpretation

Does the Mahler comparison establish an influence?

Mann offered a harmonic comparison; Lennon’s later explanation referred to Smokey Robinson. Critical resemblance alone does not establish a deliberate compositional influence. [29] [23]

Our treatmentKeep attribution explicit

References & further reading

  1. With the BeatlesWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Original release and credited compositions. Secondary overview; the original release date is corroborated by Apple’s catalog.

  2. With the BeatlesThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Official overview and an NME notice dated 15 November 1963; the notice precedes the album release.

  3. With the Beatles — Tony Barrow sleeve notesTony Barrow / Parlophone, reproduced by The Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Reproduced original notes, especially vocal and instrumental credits. The inspected source is a transcription, not an original sleeve scan. Promotional text is distinguished from independent criticism.

  4. 18 July 1963 — first album sessionThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  5. BTR 3 — Gear That Made UsAbbey Road Studios · Consulted 2026-11-15

    2 July 2022 article, first two Beatles albums. Studio account of twin-track recording and mono/stereo mixing; not a track-specific signal-chain document.

  6. I Wanna Be Your Man — recording historyThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  7. It Won’t Be LongThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  8. All I’ve Got to DoThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  9. All My LovingThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  10. All My Loving — writing and performanceThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  11. Don’t Bother MeThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  12. Don’t Bother Me — Harrison’s accountThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  13. Little ChildThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. The page retains a citation warning and a separate stereo date. These are flagged, not silently treated as a session ledger.

  14. Till There Was YouThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Composition and stage history; Beatles recording details are corroborated separately.

  15. Till There Was You — repertoire and personnelThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  16. Please Mister PostmanThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. The embedded table describes the Marvelettes original and gives five writers. It is not a Beatles recording-session credit.

  17. Roll Over BeethovenThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. The embedded table describes Chuck Berry’s original single; its 1956 date does not apply to the Beatles version.

  18. Roll Over Beethoven — performance historyThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  19. Hold Me TightThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  20. You Really Got a Hold on Me — recording historyThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  21. Devil in Her HeartThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. The page describes the Donays’ Devil in His Heart, credited to Richard Drapkin. It retains a cleanup warning.

  22. Devil in Her Heart — recording historyThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  23. Not a Second TimeThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

  24. Money (That’s What I Want) — recording historyThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  25. Robert Freeman NewsThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Apple’s 8 November 2019 tribute identifies the five Beatles album covers photographed by Freeman.

  26. Paul on Robert FreemanPaul McCartney · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Tribute dated 8 November 2019. Participant recollection of the half-shadow portrait, referring to its use on Meet the Beatles. The shared UK cover is corroborated by Apple’s tribute.

  27. With the Beatles — album chart historyOfficial Charts · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Historical peak, first chart date and number-one duration. Historical chart facts only; modern displayed catalog numbers are not treated as original vinyl identifiers.

  28. Meet the Beatles! — US programThe Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Editorial history and attributed recollections, excluding reader comments. Secondary history; books quoted by the page were not independently inspected. No lyrics reproduced.

  29. What Songs the Beatles Sang — William MannThe Times, reproduced by The Beatles Bible · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Article dated 27 December 1963. Contemporary musical criticism inspected through a secondary reproduction. Paraphrase only; includes songs outside this LP.

  30. With the Beatles — Tom Ewing reviewPitchfork · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Review dated 8 September 2009. Brief retrospective assessment; numeric reader-score widgets are not used.

  31. I Wanna Be Your ManThe Beatles / Apple Corps · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Song metadata, prose and album sequence. Legacy song metadata on the official site; recording and composition fields are read separately. No lyrics reproduced.

Additional reading

Official With the Beatles overview
Release context and a dated pre-release press excerpt.

With the Beatles on Wikipedia
Secondary overview and additional bibliography.