LinergraphResearch preview
← Album histories
THE ALBUM · RECORDING HISTORY

Animals

Pink Floyd · 1977

Britannia Row, the earlier live songs, precise performance credits, Snowy White’s cartridge-only solo, the Battersea sleeve, conflicting recollections and contemporary reviews.

2,443 words · 23 sources · Updated 2026-11-16 · Revision 7
PINK FLOYD
ANIMALS
’77

A history of Animals, assembled from release records, studio histories, archived reviews, and the evidence they leave in question.

Three animals and two short songs

Animals places three extended pieces between two short acoustic selections. Side one contains Pigs on the Wing (Part 1) and Dogs; side two has Pigs (Three Different Ones), Sheep and Pigs on the Wing (Part 2). The official history connects Roger Waters’s concept with the economic and social conditions of mid-1970s Britain and with George Orwell’s Animal Farm. The dogs, pigs and sheep characterize different kinds of human behavior and power. Pink Floyd produced the record, while the writing credits name Waters throughout and David Gilmour jointly on Dogs. [1]

The animal concept gives earlier songs a shared setting. The official history identifies You’ve Got to Be Crazy and Raving and Drooling as material set aside during Wish You Were Here because it did not fit that album’s subjects. Their developed forms became Dogs and Sheep, alongside Pigs (Three Different Ones). The two sections of Pigs on the Wing provide a more personal frame. These pieces therefore have different starting points: the finished album brings together earlier concert material and newer songs rather than documenting one uniform moment of composition. [1]

Nick Mason later told Bill Kopp that the band began by collecting songs and ideas, with the unifying concept emerging during the work. He remembered the sessions as comparatively cheerful and described working close to home among familiar people. His recollection complicates the assumption that the group spent every session in conflict. It also distinguishes this process from the more complete conceptual package he remembered receiving for The Wall. The shared studio project and the unequal distribution of formal songwriting credits are both parts of the history. [2]

Building and using Britannia Row

Pink Floyd bought a former church-hall building at 35 Britannia Row in Islington in 1975 and converted it into a recording studio and storage facility. Work on Animals began there in April 1976, with Brian Humphries engineering. Britannia Row Studios gave the group its own working base after years of recording at EMI’s Abbey Road studios and elsewhere. The original Islington site should be distinguished from the studio’s later locations. Accounts place the principal recording across much of 1976, although their descriptions of the final recording and mixing boundary vary. [3]

Mark Blake’s history identifies Humphries and Nick Griffiths working on the sessions. It also records different memories of the creative balance: Richard Wright described having little new material to offer and finding the period difficult, while Gilmour said he did not feel excluded. These statements concern particular musicians’ experiences. Wright’s lack of a formal writing credit does not mean that his keyboard playing disappeared from the record, and Gilmour’s single co-writing credit does not measure every guitar, bass or vocal contribution he made. [4]

The public MusicBrainz entry connects each original selection with Britannia Row, its underlying composition and the original engineering team. Its detailed fields also show why credits need comparison: it assigns Peter James as assistant across the tracks, while the album reference and Blake’s history identify Griffiths. The database’s fine-grained month ranges should not be read as independently verified daily session logs. Here, Humphries’s album-level engineering and Griffiths’s assistance are retained with their sources; the conflicting assistant assignment remains visible as an evidence question. [5]

The original LP, selection by selection

Pigs on the Wing is a two-part Waters composition associated in the song’s history with his relationship with Carolyne Christie. On the standard album, both short selections feature his singing and strummed acoustic guitar. Their intimacy frames the longer songs without adding the rest of the band to those two performances. The two sections have separate positions and recording identities on the LP, while belonging to the larger song. The later continuous cartridge version is another presentation, with an additional electric-guitar contribution that is absent from the standard album program. [6]

Dogs is credited to Gilmour and Waters, with Waters supplying the lyrics. Gilmour sings the earlier part of the recording and Waters the later part. The arrangement combines acoustic strumming with electric-guitar passages, Wright’s keyboards, Waters’s bass and Mason’s drums and percussion. A central section uses processed barking and electronic textures before the acoustic pattern returns. The vocal division is important: descriptions of Animals as a Waters-led album should not erase Gilmour’s lead performance, just as the writing credit should not be expanded to every musician playing the track. [7]

The earlier You’ve Got to Be Crazy changed through live performance before becoming Dogs. The song reference describes different lyrics, a faster earlier presentation and a change of key. A 1974 Wembley performance was later released with the 2011 Wish You Were Here archival editions. That placement can be misleading if an edition is mistaken for an original album: the concert recording is bonus material attached to a later Wish release, while the developed studio Dogs belongs to Animals. The two works and the two recordings retain their documented relationship. [7]

Waters wrote and sings Pigs (Three Different Ones). Gilmour plays lead guitar and bass; Waters plays rhythm guitar, while Wright contributes keyboards and Mason drums and cowbell. Gilmour’s talk-box treatment produces some of the track’s animal-like guitar sounds. The song’s third target is the British morality campaigner Mary Whitehouse. References have offered more specific identifications for the other verses, but these are less straightforward than the person actually named. The guitar effect, the bass performance and the subject of the words describe different aspects of the recording and should not be collapsed into a single generic credit. [8]

Sheep developed from Raving and Drooling and is written and sung by Waters. Wright’s Rhodes piano opens the recording against animal sounds; the song then moves into a more forceful ensemble arrangement. Gilmour plays bass as well as lead guitar, with Waters taking rhythm guitar. The middle includes a processed recitation that rewrites Psalm 23 as part of the song’s satire. Sources differ on the individual responsible for that processed voice, so its presence is described without assigning a settled spoken-performance edge. The lead vocal, keyboard and instrumental credits remain distinct from that unresolved detail. [9]

Raving and Drooling used a rearranged recording of broadcaster Jimmy Young in its live introduction. That detail does not establish that Young appears on the finished Animals master. A Wembley 1974 recording was issued in the 2011 Wish You Were Here archive program. These earlier performances document material still in development, while the original Animals selections are later studio recordings. The connections follow the versions documented rather than extending a sample, voice or touring player across every incarnation of the song. [9]

Snowy White and the eight-track version

Snowy White recalled being invited to join Pink Floyd’s touring group and then being asked to play on Pigs on the Wing while he was at the studio. In Andrew Daly’s interview, White says he picked up a white Fender Stratocaster, adjusted his sound and recorded the solo in one take. He was better known for playing a Gibson Les Paul, making his instrument choice a useful correction to assumptions based on his stage identity. This is White’s recollection of a particular performance, not proof of which guitar he used on every subsequent tour. [10]

The American eight-track cartridge combines the two Pigs on the Wing sections with White’s solo between them. Its program also divides Dogs across cartridge entries. Those divisions are format boundaries rather than additional compositions by the band. Conversely, White’s linking solo is a real difference in recorded content, so the continuous Pigs on the Wing receives a separate identity. It remains linked to the two LP sections and to the same larger Waters composition. White is credited on that version, with no guitar contribution assigned to him on the two standard LP tracks. [11]

Battersea, the escaped pig and the finished composite

Waters conceived the sleeve image and Hipgnosis realized it. Pink Floyd’s chronology dates the Battersea Power Station photography to 2–4 December 1976. On the first day, inflating the pig took so long that the photographers mainly captured the building. On the second, the inflatable broke free and eventually came down in Kent. It was recovered for the third day’s shoot. The finished cover combines the pig photographed on that third day with the power-station image from the first. A staged photograph and a composite image are therefore both involved in the sleeve’s construction. [12]

Aubrey Powell later rejected the suggestion that the escape had been planned as a publicity stunt. He recalled being on Battersea Bridge when the pig broke free and returning to the power station to deal with the situation. In the same interview, he described a later disagreement over credit for the concept: a Hipgnosis book failed to acknowledge Waters’s idea, which angered the musician. These are Powell’s accounts of the events and their aftermath. They explain why a familiar cover can carry a disputed authorship history as well as a memorable production story. [13]

The original artwork credits distinguish the concept from the people who organized and photographed it. Storm Thorgerson and Powell organized the design; Howard Bartrop receives the cover-photography credit, and Peter Christopherson appears among the other photographers. Mason supplied the lettering used in the package. The monochrome interior photographs and the animal imagery on the record labels extend the sleeve beyond the familiar front image. These are visual contributions to a music release, with their own contributors and evidence; they are not additional musical performances. [3]

The release and the expanded stage production

The official chronology places the press presentation at Battersea Power Station on 19 January 1977 and the British album release on 21 January. The original UK LP was issued by Harvest as SHVL 815. The American release followed on Columbia on 12 February, according to the same chronology. Animals reached number two in Britain and number three in the United States. The first European tour date, in Dortmund on 23 January, is distinct from the British release; references giving the same date for both need to be treated cautiously. [14]

The radio promotion produced another disagreement over an exclusive. Blake’s history records Nicky Horne preparing The Pink Floyd Story for Capital Radio, with an Animals premiere intended as its culmination. Horne recalled discovering that John Peel had played side one on the BBC first. He believed Gilmour had supplied Peel’s copy, but that identification remains Horne’s recollection. The account documents competing broadcasts around the release without turning the planned exclusive into proof that no listener could have heard the record earlier. [4]

The 1977 tour added White on guitar and bass and Dick Parry on saxophone to the four band members. The production used an inflatable pig, animated material by Gerald Scarfe and an inflatable family designed by Mark Fisher and Jonathan Park. The concert sequence differed from the LP and also included the Wish You Were Here material. Touring participation is recorded separately: Parry’s presence onstage does not create a saxophone credit on Animals, and White’s live role extends beyond his one version-specific studio contribution. [14]

Contemporary praise and rejection

Billboard gave Animals a prominent Spotlight review in its 12 February 1977 issue. The unsigned writer praised the band’s ability to make dense, unsettling studio music commercially effective and described the contrast between the acoustic framing song and the three extended pieces. The review treated the album’s animal categories as a coherent concept and commended its sustained instrumental textures. This was a favorable contemporary response aimed partly at record dealers, rather than a later reassessment based on the album’s reputation. Its description of the group as a quintet is an error and is not used as a personnel source. [15]

Beat Instrumental named Animals its Album of the Month in April 1977. The reviewer, signing T.V.S., explained that the magazine had delayed its assessment rather than print a judgment after only a few listens. The review praised the ensemble’s interaction, Wright’s keyboard choices and Gilmour’s guitar playing in the context of the songs. It regarded the album as a major achievement while resisting the idea that praising it required diminishing Dark Side. The continuation on the following page supplies the reviewer’s initials; a full personal name is not inferred from them. [16]

Frank Rose’s March 1977 Rolling Stone review was much less favorable. In the archived transcription, he found the guitar sound brittle, the singing stiff and the more elaborate production lacking depth. He also objected to what he regarded as the record’s defeatism and repetitive message. His criticism is more than a disagreement about the animal concept: it concerns the musical execution and the emotional effect of the finished album. It remains part of the contemporary reception even though many later writers have judged the same recordings more positively. [17]

Robert Christgau awarded B+, defending the album’s political program and praising its construction and emotional range while acknowledging some obvious moments. [18]

James P. Wisdom’s 2000 Pitchfork review begins with his own discovery of the record and praises Gilmour’s guitar work and Waters’s imagery. He regards the long songs and contrasting acoustic frame as strengths. His enthusiastic retrospective offers a clear counterpoint to Rose’s contemporary objections, without converting either critic’s interpretation into a new recording fact. [19]

Remixes, spatial sound and an announced anniversary

The edition titled Animals (2018 Remix) was publicly released in 2022. James Guthrie created new stereo and 5.1 presentations, with the original 1977 stereo mix also included on the Blu-ray and audio DVD. The deluxe package combined several formats with a booklet of sleeve-shoot photographs, live images and memorabilia. The title’s year therefore identifies the remix rather than the date a buyer first received that edition. Each new mix keeps its connection to the original performance and composition while remaining distinct from Humphries’s original recording work. [20]

The official announcement set 16 September 2022 for the individual formats and 7 October for the deluxe set. Powell revisited the power station for the new artwork, using fresh photographs during its conversion and digital color treatment. That revised package represents a later visual interpretation of the same album. [21]

A further Blu-ray released on 17 May 2024 added a Dolby Atmos mix by Guthrie. Paul Sinclair’s release report lists that mix alongside the earlier 5.1 and stereo remix and the original 1977 stereo. The package again revised the Battersea imagery, incorporating the light projections used for the 2022 launch. The newer spatial mix is consequently dated separately from the 2018 stereo and 5.1 work, even where the product retains the earlier remix branding. Changing the playback format does not create a newly written song or a new original-session engineer. [22]

As of 15 November 2026, Pink Floyd has announced Animals 50 for 22 January 2027. The proposed program includes earlier Dogs and Sheep versions, a studio jam, a Waters recording titled Young Nicholas Jon and a 1977 Oakland concert. The announcement also made a previously promotional Sheep radio edit commercially available. That edit is an alternate presentation of the studio recording, while the concert is a separate performance. The full anniversary package is still forthcoming at this checkpoint; its advertised contents are not described as already released or independently auditioned. [23]

Tracks & writing credits

Writing credits describe published attribution; they do not imply equal contributions.

Side one

  1. DogsDavid Gilmour and Roger Waters

Read the critics

Animals — Top Album Picks spotlight review

Billboard. Downloaded and visually inspected. Unsigned editorial review; its erroneous description of the band as a quintet is not used for personnel. Catalog number read from the scan: Columbia JC 34474.

[15]

Animals — Album of the Month

T.V.S. / Beat Instrumental. Both pages downloaded and visually inspected. The reviewer is identified only by the printed initials T.V.S.; no full name inferred. Performance descriptions are critical commentary, not session documentation.

[16]

Animals — contemporary review

Frank Rose / Rolling Stone, transcription at Pink Floyd and Company. Complete transcription inspected; original print issue not independently inspected. Critical interpretation is attributed and no song lyrics are reproduced.

[17]

Pink Floyd — Consumer Guide

Robert Christgau. Critic’s own archive. No unverified original column date assigned. Shared page allowance must cover later album discussions too.

[18]

Questions in the record

Release date

21 or 23 January?

The official chronology separates the 21 January British release from the 23 January Dortmund concert. MusicBrainz and some song histories give 23 January for release. [14] [5]

Our treatmentOfficial chronology preferred
Engineering credit

Who assisted the original engineering?

The album reference and Blake identify Nick Griffiths. MusicBrainz assigns Peter James across the tracks. The conflicting James assignment is withheld. [5] [4]

Our treatmentConflicting metadata
Voice attribution

Who performs the processed Sheep recitation?

The song reference assigns the vocoder to Mason; MusicBrainz assigns it to Waters. A named recitation credit is withheld pending stronger session evidence. [9] [5]

Our treatmentUnresolved
Session recollection

Was White replacing an erased Gilmour solo?

White recalls an invitation to improvise after agreeing to tour. His interview does not establish the erased-solo story repeated elsewhere. [10]

Our treatmentCause not established
Artistic intent

Was Animals deliberately an answer to punk?

Mason acknowledged possible influence but said the band had not discussed a deliberate response. Timing alone does not prove an agreed creative plan. [2]

Our treatmentQualified recollection
Performance credit

How precisely can the bass assignments be confirmed?

Track references credit Gilmour on Pigs and Sheep. Mason later said he could not recall the general bass-substitution story; that uncertainty is not an explicit denial. [2]

Our treatmentRetrospective uncertainty

References & further reading

  1. Animals — official album historyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Original five-selection program, production, concept and artwork. Artist history, not independent criticism. Its compressed description of the early songs does not override Gilmour’s formal Dogs co-writing credit.

  2. Nick Mason on misconceptions about AnimalsBill Kopp / Goldmine · Consulted 2026-11-15

    2022 remix interview: developing the concept, studio atmosphere, punk, The Damned and uncertain bass memories. First-person interview. Mason describes his own recollection, not a complete session log. His inability to remember bass assignments is not a categorical denial of Gilmour’s contributions.

  3. Animals — albumWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, recording, personnel and versions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and interviews not independently inspected unless separately cited. No lyrics reproduced. Uncorroborated fine-grained instrument and voice assignments remain qualified.

  4. Rioting, bitter acrimony, and the story of Pink Floyd’s AnimalsMark Blake / Classic Rock · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Recording at Britannia Row, Humphries/Griffiths, Wright/Gilmour recollections and Nicky Horne’s radio premiere. History with attributed interviews. Its 23 January release date is not adopted over the official chronology’s 21 January. Uninspected underlying memoirs and recordings are not presented as directly consulted.

  5. Animals — original British LP relationshipsMusicBrainz · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Harvest SHVL 815; displayed work and recording credits, including separate song parts. Community metadata inspected through the release page. Expanded API repeatedly returned 503. Its Peter James assistant assignment and Sheep vocoder assignment conflict with other references; these fields are not imported. Its 23 January date is qualified.

  6. Pigs on the WingWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, recording, personnel and versions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and interviews not independently inspected unless separately cited. No lyrics reproduced. Uncorroborated fine-grained instrument and voice assignments remain qualified.

  7. DogsWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, recording, personnel and versions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and interviews not independently inspected unless separately cited. No lyrics reproduced. Uncorroborated fine-grained instrument and voice assignments remain qualified.

  8. Pigs (Three Different Ones)Wikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, recording, personnel and versions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and interviews not independently inspected unless separately cited. No lyrics reproduced. Uncorroborated fine-grained instrument and voice assignments remain qualified.

  9. SheepWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, recording, personnel and versions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying books and interviews not independently inspected unless separately cited. No lyrics reproduced. Uncorroborated fine-grained instrument and voice assignments remain qualified.

  10. Snowy White on recording with Pink FloydAndrew Daly / Guitar World · Consulted 2026-11-15

    31 May 2023: invitation to tour, Pigs on the Wing and borrowed white Stratocaster. First-person account of the solo, including his one-take recollection. Does not corroborate the often repeated erased-Gilmour-solo explanation.

  11. Animals — American eight-track cartridgeMusicBrainz · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Combined Pigs on the Wing with White’s solo; split Dogs program entries. Community edition record. The continuous cartridge performance is distinct from the two LP selections. Cartridge program boundaries do not establish new compositions.

  12. Pink Floyd — 1976 chronologyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Eight months at Britannia Row; 2–4 December sleeve shoot. Retrospective official chronology. Separates the third-day pig photograph from the first-day building photograph in the composite sleeve.

  13. Aubrey Powell’s Hipgnosis storyMark Blake / Prog · Consulted 2026-11-15

    3 December 2024 republication of a 2023 interview: escaped pig and cover-concept attribution. First-person interview. Powell denies a planned publicity stunt; the account is attributed. No unsupported aviation details or medical claims adopted.

  14. Pink Floyd — 1977 chronologyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    19 January press presentation, 21 January UK release, 23 January tour start, 12 February US release and touring personnel. Retrospective dates. The UK release and Dortmund tour opening are two separate events; some references conflate them. Chart peaks refer to different national charts.

  15. Animals — Top Album Picks spotlight reviewBillboard · Consulted 2026-11-15

    12 February 1977, PDF page 80, central Spotlight panel. Downloaded and visually inspected. Unsigned editorial review; its erroneous description of the band as a quintet is not used for personnel. Catalog number read from the scan: Columbia JC 34474.

  16. Animals — Album of the MonthT.V.S. / Beat Instrumental · Consulted 2026-11-15

    April 1977, printed/PDF pages 44–45; initials at the end of the continuation. Both pages downloaded and visually inspected. The reviewer is identified only by the printed initials T.V.S.; no full name inferred. Performance descriptions are critical commentary, not session documentation.

  17. Animals — contemporary reviewFrank Rose / Rolling Stone, transcription at Pink Floyd and Company · Consulted 2026-11-15

    24 March 1977 review, reproduced in a fan-maintained archive. Complete transcription inspected; original print issue not independently inspected. Critical interpretation is attributed and no song lyrics are reproduced.

  18. Pink Floyd — Consumer GuideRobert Christgau · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Atom Heart Mother capsule, D+. Critic’s own archive. No unverified original column date assigned. Shared page allowance must cover later album discussions too.

  19. Animals — retrospective reviewJames P. Wisdom / Pitchfork · Consulted 2026-11-15

    25 April 2000: personal introduction, Gilmour’s guitar, imagery and the long-form program. Review inspected; 100-word allowance. Conflicting extracted score displays are not used as a rating.

  20. Animals (2018 Remix) — official editionPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    September 2022 release; Guthrie stereo and 5.1; original stereo and physical configurations. 2018 describes the remix, not its public release year. Blu-ray/DVD program differs from the stereo LP. Later mixing is distinct from original engineering.

  21. Pink Floyd release announcements — Animals remix and Dark Side anniversaryPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    30 June 2022: Animals remix dates and Powell artwork; 19 January, 24 March and 30 August 2023: Dark Side roles, mastering, surround mixes and standalone Blu-ray. Official edition descriptions. Later mixing and mastering are distinct from original recording. The Dark Side box also contains a separate 1974 live performance; its engineers are not credited on the studio album. One shared source record is retained for this archive URL.

  22. Animals — new Dolby Atmos Blu-rayPaul Sinclair / SuperDeluxeEdition · Consulted 2026-11-15

    14 March 2024 announcement: 17 May release, Guthrie mix, retained earlier mixes and revised package. Release report inspected. Seller links are not purchase instructions. The 2024 Atmos presentation is not dated 2018 merely because the product retains the remix branding.

  23. Pink Floyd announce Animals 50Pink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    5 November 2026: forthcoming 22 January 2027 release, rarities, radio edit and participant statements. Announcement inspected as of 15 November 2026. The full anniversary edition is forthcoming, not already released. The radio edit was made available with the announcement. Promotional aviation claims are not independently corroborated or repeated.

Additional reading