LinergraphResearch preview
← Album histories
THE ALBUM · RECORDING HISTORY

A Momentary Lapse of Reason

Pink Floyd · 1987

A new writing partnership, an expanded studio cast, and a later revision that changed the performances as well as the mix.

2,513 words · 26 sources · Updated 2026-11-16 · Revision 7
A MOMENTARY
LAPSE OF
REASON
’87

A history of A Momentary Lapse of Reason, assembled from release records, studio histories, archived reviews, and the evidence they leave in question.

Continuing after Roger Waters

A Momentary Lapse of Reason was Pink Floyd’s first studio album after Roger Waters left the group. David Gilmour and Nick Mason resumed work after their separate projects, with Bob Ezrin returning as co-producer. The official album history describes a deliberate change from the political direction of the preceding records and their overarching concepts. This album instead assembled songs on different subjects. Its production credit belongs jointly to Gilmour and Ezrin; that partnership is distinct from the songwriting credits, which vary across the program. [1]

The chronology dates British release to 7 September 1987 and the American release to the following day. It records a number-three peak in both countries. The album page pairs Yet Another Movie with Round and Around, whereas the chronology names all eleven selections. Both describe the same musical program. Here each named composition has its own entry, while the original compact-disc indexing is preserved separately. An eleven-entry display therefore does not imply that an extra song was added to the music in 2011. [2]

Richard Wright returned as a paid musician, rather than immediately resuming his former legal position in the band. The original sleeve placed him with the additional players; later reissues changed that presentation. His presence on a recording and his contractual membership are different questions. Gilmour led the project, but the credits also include numerous outside instrumentalists and writers. The dispute with Waters about continuing under the Pink Floyd name remained unresolved when the record appeared, making its release part of a contested transition rather than the consequence of an already settled reunion. [3]

Demos, Astoria and an expanded recording team

In the February 1988 Creem interview, Gilmour recalled bringing demos to sessions with Mason and Ezrin, retaining some pieces and discarding others. The ideas for The Dogs of War and Terminal Frost had existed before the album sessions. He traced part of Signs of Life to a demo from approximately 1977 or 1978: the guitar was replaced, but earlier backing chords survived. That account places composition, demo preparation and final recording in different periods. The album’s 1987 release date is not the date on which every musical idea originated. [4]

The floating Astoria studio became an important base. Gilmour told Musician in 1992 that he bought the houseboat before deciding to record there. Its large lounge became a comfortable control room, and substantial early work on the album took place aboard it. He specifically remembered recording the closing Sorrow solo through a small Gallien-Krueger amplifier on the boat. This is a location claim about that part, not proof that every element of the song was recorded in the same room. [5]

The recording credits connect London and Los Angeles. Alongside Astoria, the listed facilities include Britannia Row, Mayfair, Audio International, A&M, the Village Recorder, Can-Am and Le Mobile. Andy Jackson engineered and mixed the original album, assisted by Robert Hrycyna, Marc DeSisto, Stan Katayama and Jeff DeMorris. James Guthrie receives an additional remixing credit. These album-level credits do not establish which assistant worked on each overdub, or assign every song to every listed studio. [3]

Jon Carin recalled meeting Gilmour at the Live Aid rehearsals in 1985. In his 2007 interview he described initially declining the subsequent touring offer because he wanted to remain an artist rather than become a session musician. His contribution to Learning to Fly extended beyond playing keyboards: he shares the composition credit. Asked about its rhythmic inspiration, he pointed to the playing of Steve Jansen or Yukihiro Takahashi, rather than identifying one David Sylvian song as a source. The distinction matters: an acknowledged stylistic influence is not a sampled recording or a co-writing credit. [6]

The broader cast included Tony Levin on bass and Chapman Stick, keyboard players Carin, Patrick Leonard and Bill Payne, and saxophonists Tom Scott, Scott Page and John Helliwell. The official credits document also names Steve Forman and backing singers Darlene Koldenhoven, Carmen Twillie, Phyllis St. James and Donny Gerrard. Its edition is not securely identified, however, and it omits the guest drummers found in original-album references. It is useful corroboration of the wider cast, not a reason to replace edition-specific personnel with one universal lineup. [7]

Side one: flight, conflict and collaboration

Signs of Life is credited to Gilmour and Ezrin. Its opening water sounds came from a recording of boatman Langley Iddins rowing on the Thames; Mason supplies the processed spoken passage. Although normally classified as an instrumental, it is therefore not entirely without a human voice. The song reference credits Gilmour, Wright and Carin with keyboard or synthesizer contributions and Ezrin with sequencing and effects. It leads directly into Learning to Fly, giving the first side a connected opening without making the two pieces a single composition. [8]

Learning to Fly credits Gilmour, Anthony Moore, Ezrin and Carin. Its aviation subject connects to Gilmour’s flying lessons; Mason’s spoken cockpit passage adds another pilot’s voice. The song also became a way of discussing the band’s new circumstances, although that metaphor should not erase its literal aviation imagery. The studio reference credits Gilmour with the guitar solos and Mason with drums. Later concerts gave the solos to Tim Renwick. A concert credit cannot therefore be transferred unchanged to the original studio master simply because the song title is identical. [9]

The Dogs of War brings Moore into the writing partnership again. Its subject is the relationship between power, money and warfare. The original studio personnel differ substantially from the touring lineup: Carmine Appice is the credited drummer, Payne plays Hammond organ, and Page and Scott provide saxophones. Gilmour sings and plays guitar, with Levin on bass and Carin on keyboards. The later concert arrangement extended the introductions, solo exchanges and ending. Those structural differences help explain why a performance video is insufficient evidence for the personnel or exact arrangement of the album recording. [10]

One Slip, written by Gilmour and Phil Manzanera, supplies the phrase used as the album title. Its recorded rhythm section includes Levin’s Chapman Stick and Jim Keltner’s drums, with Mason credited for percussion. The track reference identifies keyboard parts by Ezrin and Carin. It subsequently became a single, with a shorter edit, and remained part of the touring repertoire. Its 2019 reconstruction changes both drums and organ: Mason supplies newly recorded drums, while Wright’s organ is drawn from performances on the 1987–1989 tour. [11]

Michael Landau provided the delayed guitar part on One Slip. In Guitar World he recalled Ezrin bringing him into the session, playing while Gilmour listened from the control room, and making a few passes at the requested part. He thought he might also have played on another song but could not remember its title. The same interview connects him with Ringo Starr: he remembered Don Was recruiting him for Time Takes Time sessions, with Starr playing nearby. These are specific working connections; Landau’s uncertain additional Floyd song remains unidentified. [12]

On the Turning Away closes the first side. Moore and Gilmour share its writing credit, and the song’s concern with refusing indifference gives the album a political strand despite its move away from a single political concept. Gilmour has said that he rewrote the final verse. The studio reference assigns him vocals, guitars and fretless bass, with Keltner on drums, Carin on synthesizer and Wright on organ and backing vocals. The separate live personnel list includes Guy Pratt, Mason and Renwick; it should not substitute for the studio list. [13]

Side two: linked pieces and Sorrow

Yet Another Movie credits Gilmour and Leonard. It began as an instrumental before words were added, and the released recording includes film dialogue from One-Eyed Jacks and Casablanca. Its personnel reference distinguishes Mason’s drums in the middle section from Keltner’s drumming, rather than reducing the track to a single undifferentiated drum credit. Leonard and Carin contribute keyboards, with Levin on bass, Forman on percussion and Helliwell on saxophone. The later publication of a Gilmour–Leonard instrumental demo provides a different stage of the work, not another name for the finished album performance. [14]

Round and Around follows as a short instrumental credited solely to Gilmour. It originally shared track six with Yet Another Movie, using the second index within that track; the 2011 remastered CD separated the pieces into their own tracks. The distinction is more than a numbering detail: Leonard’s credit on Yet Another Movie does not make him a credited writer of Round and Around. The latter’s listed performers are Gilmour on guitar and sequencer, Carin on keyboards and Levin on bass. [15]

The two parts of A New Machine frame Terminal Frost. Each is credited to Gilmour. His electronically treated voice, vocoder and synthesizer form the core of the two short vocal passages, with Leonard also listed on synthesizer. Their narrative concerns bodily confinement and waiting, but its emotional meaning admits more than one reading. In his Musician interview Gilmour declined to settle whether it should be understood as optimistic or pessimistic. The two named parts remain distinct album selections even though they share a title and form a deliberate pair. [16] [5]

Terminal Frost is an instrumental credited to Gilmour, situated between those vocal pieces. Tom Scott and John Helliwell play its saxophones; Helliwell’s participation links the sessions to Supertramp. The reference lists Wright’s piano, Kurzweil synthesizer and Hammond organ, with additional keyboard or programming contributions by Ezrin and Carin. Mason is credited with electronic drums, and Levin with bass. Its classification as an instrumental does not exclude wordless backing vocals: the personnel list also names Koldenhoven, Twillie, St. James and Gerrard. [17]

Sorrow closes the album with a different drum history. Gilmour programmed the original rhythm; Mason’s acoustic drum performance belongs to the later revised version. The song reference also credits Wright’s synthesizer, Ezrin’s keyboards, Levin’s bass and the backing singers. It distinguishes the guitar introduction, treated through the band’s sound system at the Los Angeles Memorial Sports Arena, from the closing solo recorded aboard Astoria. Those accounts describe different parts of the record and need not be competing claims about a single session. [18]

Gilmour’s July 1988 Guitar World interview gives a more detailed account of Sorrow’s sound. He described using a Steinberger guitar with a Boss distortion pedal and digital delay, a Fender Super Champ and the distortion from a Gallien-Krueger amplifier. He also recalled writing the words before the music, an unusual order for him, then trying the recently acquired instrument the next day. The interview identifies the guitar on Signs of Life as recorded directly into the desk. These details come from the guitarist’s account; they do not establish a complete equipment inventory for every track. [19]

A constructed landscape and a returning live band

Storm Thorgerson’s cover was made by arranging real beds on a beach. In his Floydian Slip interview he recalled hundreds of heavy wrought-iron beds being individually positioned, only for rain to obscure the distant rows. The installation had to be taken down and attempted again. His preference was to construct and photograph a scene rather than rely on a wholly computer-created image. That account explains the physical work behind the sleeve, while leaving the precise bed count open: his recollections and later publicity do not all give the same number. [20]

Thorgerson gave Steven Cerio a similar description of the failed first shoot and its repetition after a two-week wait. He estimated approximately 750 beds and described about thirty people moving them. The repeated accounts support the basic production story more strongly than they establish an exact inventory. Their language also shows his intention: the photograph was supposed to convey the scale of an improbable but real installation. Treating every remembered number as exact would disguise the difference between a participant’s retrospective interview and a surviving production record. [21]

Tour rehearsals began on 1 August 1987 at a warehouse facility at Toronto’s Pearson airport. It names Gilmour, Mason and Wright alongside Guy Pratt, Carin, Page, Gary Wallis, Tim Renwick, Rachel Fury and Margaret Taylor. The North American tour opened in Ottawa on 9 September. This touring ensemble was not identical to the studio cast: Pratt took the bass position, for example, rather than Levin. The difference created another set of performances and relationships as the recorded arrangements were adapted for the stage. [2]

Critical responses, then and after the remix

Creem’s February 1988 feature offered a strongly favorable contemporary assessment, presenting the record as Gilmour’s achievement and describing a revitalized live band. Its opening argument credited his voice, guitar and writing with balancing Waters’s contributions in earlier Pink Floyd. That position framed the new record as evidence of continuing musical identity. It was an editorial interpretation made alongside an interview with Gilmour and Mason, not an agreed verdict from the departed and remaining members. [4]

Mark Peel’s December 1987 Stereo Review assessment reached a more skeptical conclusion. He recognized Gilmour as a central musical force and praised the band’s ability to create atmosphere, especially in Signs of Life, The Dogs of War and Terminal Frost. Yet he found the themes conventional and their development predictable, arguing that the album lacked the unifying purpose Waters would have supplied. His objection was therefore not simply that the musicians could no longer reproduce familiar sounds; it was that successfully reproducing them did not amount to taking new artistic risks. [22]

Reviewing The Later Years in 2019, John Kelman at All About Jazz welcomed the revised album. He heard Mason’s less crowded drumming and the increased prominence of Wright’s keyboards as bringing it closer to the band’s character. He particularly discussed the altered instrumental balance in Learning to Fly and The Dogs of War, while finding Gilmour’s playing largely preserved. This is a favorable assessment of a reconstruction released decades later. It should not be presented as a review written at the original release, or as independent proof of every original performer credit. [23]

David Stubbs’s Classic Rock review of the reworked edition remained considerably less enthusiastic. He preferred the two brief A New Machine passages, finding their combination of voice and electronic processing more distinctive than much of the surrounding material. Learning to Fly, Yet Another Movie and Terminal Frost did not convince him that the revision solved the album’s limitations. Read beside Kelman, his response shows that changes in instrumental balance did not produce a critical consensus. The disagreement concerns musical results, not merely whether the later release contains different performances. [24]

What the later edition actually changes

Engineer Andy Jackson explained the reconstruction in a 2019 Forbes interview. Mason recorded new drum parts, while Jackson searched recordings of the Momentary Lapse tour for Wright’s playing after plans to bring Wright back into the studio could no longer be fulfilled. He also identified a replacement Gilmour lead vocal on On the Turning Away, taken from a concert performance. These are changes to the performance material, not just equalization or remastering. The original 1987 recordings and the revised stereo versions consequently have separate identities here, linked to the same underlying compositions. [25]

The revised album first appeared in The Later Years and received a separate physical release on 29 October 2021. The announcement credits remixing to Jackson with Gilmour, assisted by Damon Iddins, with additional editing by Devin Workman. It also describes a new cover using an alternative Robert Dowling photograph from the original shoot, with artwork by Aubrey Powell and Peter Curzon. Its double-LP sequence occupies four sides, with Sorrow alone on the fourth. That configuration is distinct from the original two-sided album and from the eleven-track CD. [26]

Tracks & writing credits

Writing credits describe published attribution; they do not imply equal contributions.

Side one

  1. Signs of LifeDavid Gilmour / Bob Ezrin
  2. Learning to FlyDavid Gilmour / Anthony Moore / Bob Ezrin / Jon Carin
  3. The Dogs of WarDavid Gilmour / Anthony Moore
  4. One SlipDavid Gilmour / Phil Manzanera
  5. On the Turning AwayDavid Gilmour / Anthony Moore

Read the critics

The Sun Is Eclipsed by the Moon

Creem / A Fleeting Glimpse transcript. Magazine interview hosted as a transcript. The original printed pages were not examined. Interviewer’s positive assessment is distinguished from the musicians’ recollections.

[4]

Pink Floyd’s Brilliant Formula

Mark Peel / Stereo Review. Complete indexed review text and byline inspected. Direct PDF returned 403; page image was not inspected. Critical judgments remain attributed.

[22]

Questions in the record

Session chronology

Did recording begin in January 1987?

The official chronology starts sessions in January. Gilmour’s Creem account describes earlier demo work and a September gathering. These sources do not establish one day on which every kind of album work began. [2] [4]

Our treatmentDifferent stages need distinguishing
Indexing and composition

Does the album have ten tracks or eleven?

Movie and Round share original CD track six, with Round at index two. Later CDs separate them. Eleven named selections here preserve both compositions without calling Round a newly added bonus song. [15]

Our treatmentEdition distinction
Personnel provenance

Which credits belong to which version?

The indexed official credits document lacks Keltner and Appice and does not securely identify its edition. Original-song references retain their drum credits. Newly recorded Mason drums belong to the later reconstruction. [7] [25]

Our treatmentDo not merge editions
Performance provenance

Are all restored Wright parts unused studio takes?

The announcement emphasizes unused original parts; Jackson also describes extracting Wright’s playing from concert recordings. Neither account supports calling all restored keyboards new studio performances or assigning every keyboard part to Wright. [26] [25]

Our treatmentAnnouncement needs qualification
Uncertain recollection

Which other track did Landau play on?

Landau remembered possibly playing on another song, but could not name it. One Slip is supported; the unnamed possibility is not converted into another track credit. [12]

Our treatmentUnidentified
Conflicting recollections

Exactly how many beds were on the cover?

Thorgerson recalled 700 beds to Floydian Slip and approximately 750 to Cerio. Later publicity refers to 500. The photographic installation is established; its exact count remains unresolved here. [20] [21] [26]

Our treatmentApproximate accounts
Influence and attribution

Was Learning to Fly based on one Sylvian song?

Carin rejected that formulation in his 2007 interview, describing a rhythmic influence from Jansen or Takahashi instead. His criticism of earlier reported quotations is preserved as his account. [6]

Our treatmentSpecific source not identified

References & further reading

  1. A Momentary Lapse of Reason — official album historyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    September 1987; five entries on each side, Movie/Round paired; Gilmour/Ezrin production. Artist retrospective, separate from the later Remixed & Updated edition.

  2. Pink Floyd — 1987 chronologyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    January session entry; 7 September UK / 8 September US; eleven named selections; Toronto rehearsals and Ottawa opening. Official retrospective. Its January start does not account for the earlier demo work described by participants.

  3. A Momentary Lapse of Reason — albumWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  4. The Sun Is Eclipsed by the MoonCreem / A Fleeting Glimpse transcript · Consulted 2026-11-15

    February 1988 interview with Gilmour and Mason; demo chronology, title and contemporary assessment. Magazine interview hosted as a transcript. The original printed pages were not examined. Interviewer’s positive assessment is distinguished from the musicians’ recollections.

  5. Careful with That Axe — David Gilmour interviewMatt Resnicoff / Musician transcript · Consulted 2026-11-15

    August 1992; Astoria working environment, Sorrow closing solo, solo-album comparison. Firsthand interview hosted in an archive; not an independently inspected multitrack log.

  6. Jon Carin interviewArash Danesh / Brain Damage · Consulted 2026-11-15

    17 August 2007; Live Aid meeting, tour offer, Learning to Fly rhythmic influence and disputed quotations. Firsthand account. His criticism of a previous interview remains an attributed allegation, not an adjudicated finding.

  7. A Momentary Lapse of Reason — official credits documentPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Indexed credits: eleven selections, personnel, studios, writers and engineering. Direct URL returned 404. Indexed text was inspected. Edition is not securely identified and guest drummers are absent, so this document is not used to erase original 1987 credits.

  8. Signs of LifeWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  9. Learning to FlyWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  10. The Dogs of WarWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  11. One SlipWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  12. Michael Landau — session work and the Coma StratocasterAmit Sharma / Guitar World · Consulted 2026-11-15

    24 May 2023; One Slip delay guitar, Ezrin invitation, uncertain additional track and Ringo sessions. Firsthand recollection. The unnamed possible second Floyd track is not assigned a performance credit.

  13. On the Turning AwayWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  14. Yet Another MovieWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  15. Round and AroundWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  16. A New MachineWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  17. Terminal FrostWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  18. SorrowWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Composition, original recording personnel and version distinctions. Secondary reference inspected; underlying session sheets and cited books were not independently examined. Track-level credits retain the reference’s stated scope. No lyrics reproduced.

  19. David Gilmour: Absolute SoundBill Milkowski / Guitar World · Consulted 2026-11-15

    July 1988 interview, republished 4 March 2022; Sorrow equipment and writing, Signs of Life direct recording. Publisher-hosted archive. The fictional future scenario in the introduction is satire, not biographical evidence.

  20. Storm Thorgerson interviewCraig Bailey / Floydian Slip · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Real beds, rain, repeated installation and preference for photographing constructed scenes. Firsthand retrospective. This interview says 700 beds; other accounts differ. No exact total is asserted as settled.

  21. Storm Thorgerson interview — Seconds 46Steven Cerio / Seconds · Consulted 2026-11-15

    1998 interview republished by its author; approximately 750 beds and repeated beach shoot. Firsthand recollection with an approximate count, not a production inventory.

  22. Pink Floyd’s Brilliant FormulaMark Peel / Stereo Review · Consulted 2026-11-15

    December 1987, printed page 159. Complete indexed review text and byline inspected. Direct PDF returned 403; page image was not inspected. Critical judgments remain attributed.

  23. Pink Floyd: The Later Years: 1987–2019John Kelman / All About Jazz · Consulted 2026-11-15

    8 December 2019, A Momentary Lapse section. Review of the revised edition within a box set. Not a contemporary 1987 review or an original-session personnel ledger.

  24. Pink Floyd’s reworked A Momentary Lapse of Reason fails to flyDavid Stubbs / Classic Rock · Consulted 2026-11-15

    Reissue review; page updated 20 September 2022. Opinion about the 2019 rework in its later release context; update date is not the original album date.

  25. Pink Floyd’s A Momentary Lapse of Reason Gets an Update Three Decades LaterDavid Chiu / Forbes · Consulted 2026-11-15

    9 December 2019; Andy Jackson interview about new drums, Wright concert tapes and alternate Turning Away vocal. Accessible tool-rendered interview text inspected. Jackson’s detailed provenance is more specific than the release announcement’s shorthand about restored keyboard parts.

  26. A Momentary Lapse of Reason — Remixed & Updated announcementPink Floyd / Warner Music / Sony Music · Consulted 2026-11-15

    2 September 2021 press release; 29 October physical release; remix team, revised artwork and format sequences. Text layer inspected. Promotional claims of improved sound are attributed intentions, not objective measurements. No PDF artwork reproduced.

Additional reading

Official album history
Original side sequence, production and artwork.

A Momentary Lapse of Reason on Wikipedia
Album overview and bibliography.

Michael Landau’s session recollections
One Slip, Ezrin’s invitation and work with Ringo Starr.