A history of Obscured by Clouds, assembled from release records, studio histories, archived reviews, and the evidence they leave in question.
A second album for Barbet Schroeder
Pink Floyd made Obscured by Clouds for Barbet Schroeder’s film La Vallée, returning to the director after their collaboration on More. The album contains ten selections, six on the first LP side and four on the second. Pink Floyd produced it, and Hipgnosis supplied the artwork. The official history describes the commission arriving while the band was developing The Dark Side of the Moon in concert. Instead of another side-long composition like Echoes, this project required shorter pieces suited to the film’s scenes. The finished album includes both songs and instrumental tracks. [1]
Mason later defended that approach in an interview preserved by the Brain Damage archive and dated March 1973. Asked whether the film project had failed, he said the musicians were pleased with their contribution. He described a sequence of songs balanced through contrasting tempos and rhythms, rather than the sustained conception he associated with Meddle and The Dark Side of the Moon. That account helps explain the record’s structure without turning his personal assessment into a critical consensus. The archive does not identify the original French interviewer or publication, so the transcript’s provenance remains incomplete. [2]
Two French visits and a London mix
The official chronology dates the first week at Château d’Hérouville to 23 February 1972. After a Japanese tour, the band returned on 23 March for four days, completing mixing at Morgan Studios on 6 April. The Dark Side of the Moon was already being performed publicly; the projects overlapped. [3]
Ginger Gilmour’s memoir describes living at the château with the musicians and touring crew. The band repeatedly watched the film while working to an intense schedule; meals, sleep and recording all took place at the residential studio. She remembers the project as taking two weeks and contrasts its short pieces with the spacious development of Echoes. Her description also records the ordinary social life surrounding the work: communal dinners and the crew’s eating contests. The recollection gives a participant’s view of the atmosphere, while the dated chronology separates the two visits and subsequent London mixing. [4]
The studio was part of a historic property at Hérouville-en-Vexin, northeast of Pontoise. The Île-de-France regional authority credits composer Michel Magne with establishing its residential recording operation. Its heritage account lists Pink Floyd alongside Elton John, David Bowie, Iggy Pop and the Bee Gees among the artists associated with the site. Their connection is to a place, not necessarily to one another’s sessions. The château and studio received regional heritage recognition in September 2025. [5]
Chris Michie’s account of the recording work
A professional biography accompanying Chris Michie’s April 1981 article in Recording Engineer/Producer identifies him as an engineer on Obscured by Clouds. It places his earlier career at AIR, where he worked on Stevie Wonder’s Talking Book sessions and assisted Pink Floyd on Meddle. It also describes his move into the band’s live sound operation and subsequent touring. This supplies a documented connection across the two Pink Floyd albums, while leaving the individual takes and exact allocation of engineering work unspecified. The credit belongs to the sound engineer and technical writer; it should not be merged with the American guitarist also named Chris Michie. [6]
The film and the album have different programs
La Vallée follows a wealthy woman who joins an expedition seeking a remote valley in New Guinea. The producer and distributor, Les Films du Losange, credits Schroeder with the screenplay, Nestor Almendros with photography, Jean-Pierre Ruh with sound, and Denise de Casabianca with editing. The cast includes Bulle Ogier, Jean-Pierre Kalfon and Michael Gothard. Pink Floyd receives the music credit. These jobs belong to the film: Ruh’s location-sound credit, for example, does not establish that he engineered the château album sessions. [7]
The Museum of Modern Art’s screening note describes Ogier’s character as the wife of a French diplomat in Melbourne. It interprets the journey as a questioning of the travelers’ search for enlightenment and the colonial clichés surrounding it. That is the museum’s reading of a fictional film. It does not establish that the travelers’ assumptions describe the people or places they encounter accurately. The film’s narrative provides the commission’s context, while its soundtrack remains only one part of its construction. [8]
The artist’s album history says the music often enters scenes through car radios. It also identifies Mudmen and Stay as album selections not used in the film. A soundtrack album is therefore not automatically a complete transcription of the music heard on screen. [1]
Obscured by Clouds and When You’re In
The opening title track combines Gilmour’s electric guitar, Waters’s bass, Wright’s organ and synthesizer, and Mason’s acoustic and electronic drums. When You’re In follows with guitar, bass, drums, Hammond organ and piano in its recording credits. [9]
The later edition’s metadata preserves the different writing partnerships: Gilmour and Waters for the title track, and all four members for When You’re In. Its broad composer/lyricist category does not mean these instrumental pieces have sung words. Both original performances were subsequently remixed for the archival release. [10]
Burning Bridges and the related Mudmen
Burning Bridges combines Wright’s music with Waters’s words. Gilmour and Wright share the singing, making the vocal performance a partnership different from the writing partnership. The track reference describes a melody developed at the organ and a six-beat meter. Gilmour contributes electric and slide guitar, Wright Hammond organ, Waters bass, and Mason drums and percussion. The gentle duet is consequently neither a Gilmour solo song nor evidence that Waters sings the lead simply because he supplied the lyrics. [11]
Mudmen returns to related musical material without the sung text. Its credited writers are Wright and Gilmour. The instrumental has a different meter from Burning Bridges. [12]
The recording metadata lists Gilmour’s guitars and Wright’s piano, organ, electric piano, synthesizer and vibraphone, with Waters’s bass and Mason’s drums. These are community-maintained credits, rather than a newly inspected session ledger. [9]
Two Gilmour–Waters songs on side one
The Gold It’s in the… is sung by Gilmour and credited to Gilmour and Waters. The later edition retains Gilmour’s guitar and vocal roles and Mason’s drums. Its broad personnel fields do not resolve the original bass-credit disagreement documented below. [10]
Wot’s… Uh the Deal? is another Gilmour–Waters collaboration, with Gilmour singing and playing acoustic and lap-steel guitars. Wright’s piano and Hammond organ, Waters’s bass and Mason’s drums complete the listed arrangement. The track reference connects its unusual title phrase to road-crew member Chris Adamson. It also records the song’s later return in Gilmour’s 2006 solo concerts, where Wright again participated. Those performances subsequently appeared in the Remember That Night and Live in Gdańsk release history. They are later performances of the composition, not additional personnel for the 1972 studio master. The revived arrangement gives the song a documented life beyond its original soundtrack setting. [13]
Childhood’s End: Gilmour as sole writer
Childhood’s End opens the second side. Gilmour is its sole credited writer and lead singer, and plays acoustic and electric guitars. Wright contributes organ and synthesizer, with Waters on bass and Mason on drums. The song reference identifies it as Gilmour’s last solely written Pink Floyd lyric until A Momentary Lapse of Reason in 1987. Its title has often been linked to Arthur C. Clarke’s novel, but the compared references differ in how confidently they make that connection. The common title alone cannot establish a precise adaptation of the book. The song also entered the band’s 1972–73 live repertoire, where the arrangement could expand beyond the studio recording. [14]
Free Four: Waters’s song beneath the buoyant arrangement
Free Four is written and sung by Waters. The song reference contrasts its upbeat presentation with reflections on mortality, the recording business and the death of his father during the Second World War. Its personnel include Waters’s bass and layered vocals, Gilmour’s electric guitar, Wright’s synthesizer, and Mason’s drums and tambourine. The opening count-in leads into a compact song rather than a continuous album suite. Free Four was also issued as an American single with Stay. The single reference describes a shorter edit, which should not be substituted for the album recording merely because both versions share a title. The acoustic-guitar attribution differs between the album and song references and remains unresolved here. [15]
Stay and the recorded voices in Absolutely Curtains
Stay gives Wright lead vocal and piano, with Gilmour on guitar and backing vocals, Waters on bass, and Mason on drums. Absolutely Curtains instead lists Wright’s keyboards, Mason’s percussion and recorded Mapuga voices. Its quartet writing credit does not establish guitar and bass performances. [9]
The album account identifies the closing voices as a chant taken from La Vallée. The incorporated vocal recording is distinct from the Pink Floyd studio performance. The available references identify a community designation but do not name individual singers or establish authorship of the chant. [12]
A blurred film image and a June release
The cover uses a deliberately blurred frame from the film, showing a man in a tree. The album reference associates it with a moment when the projector jammed and recounts Hipgnosis’s decision to preserve the unfocused image. The design thus connects the sleeve directly to the film without presenting a conventional band portrait. [12]
The official chronology gives 2 June 1972 as the British release date and reports a UK chart peak of six. [3]
The British Harvest catalog number is SHSP 4020. [9]
Record World’s 17 June issue identifies the American Harvest release as ST-11078, distributed through Capitol. Its album-review column says the film had not yet been released in America. The album’s availability and the film’s local release therefore had separate histories. The issue itself supplies contemporary evidence of the record’s reception, rather than a verified first day of retail sale. [16]
Critics disagree about the soundtrack form
Record World’s unsigned contemporary review was strongly favorable. It praised the band’s distinctive approach to space-oriented rock and argued that Pink Floyd benefited from working within a concept. That judgment treats the soundtrack commission as a productive framework. It does not name a single standout song or supply a numerical rating. [16]
Robert Christgau’s Consumer Guide capsule reaches the opposite conclusion, assigning C and dismissing the collection of film songs. His negative verdict is preserved alongside the favorable contemporary notice rather than averaged into a score that neither critic gave. [17]
Ryan Reed’s 2012 Ultimate Classic Rock reassessment argues that the album deserves attention despite being overshadowed by Meddle and The Dark Side of the Moon. He particularly values Mudmen’s atmosphere and the acoustic writing of Wot’s… Uh the Deal, while finding The Gold It’s in the… less convincing. His argument is for an uneven but rewarding collection, not for every track being equally successful. The review also compares this commission favorably with the earlier soundtrack work, a judgment about artistic results rather than a claim that the two films shared a recording session. [18]
The available AllMusic review passages are more qualified. They characterize the record as recognizably soundtrack music while singling out The Gold It’s in the…, Childhood’s End and Free Four. The latter pair’s concerns with life, death and the past are read as anticipating The Dark Side of the Moon. That assessment differs from Reed’s response to The Gold It’s in the…, showing disagreement even among critics who find important material here. These comments describe the indexed passages that could be inspected; they do not stand in for an unseen full-page rating. [19]
Ballet, remastering and a later complete remix
The official chronology also places Obscured by Clouds and When You’re In in the music for Roland Petit’s Pink Floyd Ballet, performed with the band in Marseille in November 1972. This is a stage use of the compositions, not proof that the dancers appeared on the album. [3]
Legacy Recordings announced a vinyl remaster for 23 September 2016, alongside Atom Heart Mother and Meddle, describing a return to the original analogue tapes. That vinyl release is a later edition of the album. It is distinct from the new mix prepared for The Early Years. [20]
The official 1972 Obfusc/ation inventory credits Andy Jackson and Damon Iddins with remixing all ten album tracks in 2016. The volume also includes a separately identified Pompeii program, a Pop Deux documentary showing the Obscured by Clouds work, and French television material about the ballet. The album remixes reuse the original performances; they are not ten newly performed songs. Jackson and Iddins consequently connect to those later mixes, while Michie’s original recording work remains attached to the 1972 project. [21]
Qobuz dates the digital 1972 Obfusc/ation edition to 24 March 2017 and explicitly labels its album tracks as 2016 remixes. The difference between the mixing year and the edition’s release year is meaningful. This edition also includes Pompeii performances; it is an archival collection containing the remixed album, not another studio-album project in the band’s original catalog. [10]
Tracks & writing credits
Writing credits describe published attribution; they do not imply equal contributions.
Side one
- Obscured by CloudsDavid Gilmour and Roger Waters
- When You’re InDavid Gilmour, Roger Waters, Richard Wright and Nick Mason
- Burning BridgesRichard Wright and Roger Waters
- The Gold It’s in the…David Gilmour and Roger Waters
- Wot’s… Uh the Deal?David Gilmour and Roger Waters
- MudmenRichard Wright and David Gilmour
Side two
- Childhood’s EndDavid Gilmour
- Free FourRoger Waters
- StayRichard Wright and Roger Waters
- Absolutely CurtainsDavid Gilmour, Roger Waters, Richard Wright and Nick Mason
Read the critics
Obscured by Clouds — Album Picks
Record World. Unsigned contemporary review downloaded and visually inspected. The issue date is not proof of the American first-sale date.
[16]Pink Floyd — Consumer Guide
Robert Christgau. Critic’s own archive. No unverified original column date assigned. Shared page allowance must cover later album discussions too.
[17]Why Pink Floyd’s Obscured by Clouds deserves another look
Ryan Reed / Ultimate Classic Rock. Review inspected in indexed full text. Its erroneous Barrett/Saucerful chronology and speculative medical wording are excluded; live-DVD title is corrected against the song reference.
[18]Obscured by Clouds — album review
AllMusic. Direct page returned 403. Only the available indexed review passages support the paraphrase; no unseen rating or text is asserted.
[19]Questions in the record
Was the UK release on 2 or 3 June?
The artist chronology gives 2 June; MusicBrainz gives 3 June for SHSP 4020. The discrepancy remains explicit. [3] [9]
Did recording end in February?
The remix inventory lists 23–29 February. The chronology also records four days from 23 March and April mixing at Morgan. [21] [3]
Who plays bass on The Gold It’s in the…?
MusicBrainz names Waters; the album reference allows Gilmour. No individual bass credit is accepted pending stronger evidence. [9] [12]
Who plays the acoustic guitar on Free Four?
The album account names Waters; the song reference and MusicBrainz name Gilmour. The acoustic-guitar credit remains unresolved. [12] [15] [9]
Does Childhood’s End adapt Clarke’s novel?
The song reference asserts inspiration from Clarke; the album account is tentative. A matching title does not settle the connection. [14] [12]
Who are the individual singers at the close?
The official chronology identifies Mapuga singers without individual names or a precise recording date. That limited identification is preserved. [3]
When was the original American LP released?
The chronology gives 17 June; the album reference gives 15 June. Both place the US release in June 1972. [3] [12]
References & further reading
- Obscured by Clouds — official album historyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15
Ten-track original program, production, artwork and relationship to La Vallée. Artist account, not independent criticism. Says Mudmen and Stay are absent from the film.
- Nick Mason — March 1973 interview in FranceBrain Damage interview archive · Consulted 2026-11-15
Answers concerning La Vallée and the album’s succession of songs. Fan-hosted English transcript explicitly says the interviewer and original publication are unknown. Attributed testimony with this provenance limitation, not independently authenticated original print.
- Pink Floyd — 1972 chronologyPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15
February and March Château sessions, April Morgan mixing, June release and November ballet. Retrospective official chronology. Its track list omits Childhood’s End; the complete album page takes precedence. US date and chart peak conflict with the album reference.
- Memoirs of the Bright Side of the Moon — authorized excerptGinger Gilmour / BookLife · Consulted 2026-11-15
Chapter 6, printed page 43 (PDF page 2): Château d’Hérouville in 1972. Participant memoir excerpt downloaded and visually inspected; book identity checked against BookLife project 11710. The remembered two-week duration is not a complete dated session log.
- Château d’Hérouville receives regional heritage recognitionRégion Île-de-France · Consulted 2026-11-15
25 September 2025: Château d’Hérouville section, location, Michel Magne and residential studio. Regional authority’s heritage account. Shared use of the studio does not establish collaboration between its recording artists.
- On the road with Britannia Row: The Stevie Wonder TourChris Michie / Recording Engineer/Producer · Consulted 2026-11-15
April 1981, printed/PDF page 46: author biography identifies AIR, Meddle and Obscured by Clouds. Professional biography accompanying Michie’s own article; page downloaded and visually inspected. Sound engineer and technical writer, not the American guitarist of the same name. Compressed intervals in the career summary are not adopted as exact session dates.
- The Valley / Obscured by Clouds — film creditsLes Films du Losange · Consulted 2026-11-15
1972 film: screenplay, cast, photography, sound, editing and music. Producer/distributor record. English page’s release-date formatting is not used to establish a premiere date. Film crew roles do not become album engineering credits.
- La vallée — screening and film interpretationMuseum of Modern Art · Consulted 2026-11-15
Film synopsis and interpretation of Ogier’s character and the expedition. Museum screening note; its interpretation is attributed. The film’s representation of Indigenous people is not treated as ethnographic evidence.
- Obscured by Clouds — original UK release and recording relationshipsMusicBrainz · Consulted 2026-11-15
Harvest SHSP 4020; ten tracks and expanded recording relationships inspected through the public JSON API. Community metadata, not original session sheets. The UK date is 3 June rather than the official chronology’s 2 June. Gold bass and Free Four acoustic-guitar disagreements are not silently resolved. Recording relationships do not establish a full attendance register.
- 1972 Obfusc/ation — digital editionQobuz / Pink Floyd Records · Consulted 2026-11-15
24 March 2017 release date; ten remixed album tracks followed by Pompeii recordings. Retailer-supplied edition metadata. Broad instrument and composer/lyricist labels are not substituted for track-specific original credits. The reproduced TiVo review is not used as an additional independent review.
- Burning BridgesWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, personnel, recording and release sections. Secondary reference inspected. Underlying books and session documents were not independently inspected. Conflicting credits remain explicit; no lyrics reproduced.
- Obscured by CloudsWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, personnel, recording and release sections. Secondary reference inspected. Underlying books and session documents were not independently inspected. Conflicting credits remain explicit; no lyrics reproduced.
- Wot’s… Uh the Deal?Wikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, personnel, recording and release sections. Secondary reference inspected. Underlying books and session documents were not independently inspected. Conflicting credits remain explicit; no lyrics reproduced.
- Childhood’s EndWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, personnel, recording and release sections. Secondary reference inspected. Underlying books and session documents were not independently inspected. Conflicting credits remain explicit; no lyrics reproduced.
- Free FourWikipedia · Consulted 2026-11-15
Composition, personnel, recording and release sections. Secondary reference inspected. Underlying books and session documents were not independently inspected. Conflicting credits remain explicit; no lyrics reproduced.
- Obscured by Clouds — Album PicksRecord World · Consulted 2026-11-15
17 June 1972, printed/PDF page 35; Harvest ST-11078 (Capitol). Unsigned contemporary review downloaded and visually inspected. The issue date is not proof of the American first-sale date.
- Pink Floyd — Consumer GuideRobert Christgau · Consulted 2026-11-15
Atom Heart Mother capsule, D+. Critic’s own archive. No unverified original column date assigned. Shared page allowance must cover later album discussions too.
- Why Pink Floyd’s Obscured by Clouds deserves another lookRyan Reed / Ultimate Classic Rock · Consulted 2026-11-15
Updated 4 June 2012: retrospective assessment of Mudmen, Wot’s… Uh the Deal and The Gold It’s in the…. Review inspected in indexed full text. Its erroneous Barrett/Saucerful chronology and speculative medical wording are excluded; live-DVD title is corrected against the song reference.
- Obscured by Clouds — album reviewAllMusic · Consulted 2026-11-15
Indexed review passages: soundtrack form, The Gold It’s in the…, Childhood’s End and Free Four. Direct page returned 403. Only the available indexed review passages support the paraphrase; no unseen rating or text is asserted.
- Atom Heart Mother, Meddle and Obscured by Clouds return to vinylLegacy Recordings / PR Newswire · Consulted 2026-11-15
18 August 2016 announcement of 23 September releases. Label announcement establishes date and analogue-source remaster description, not an independently verified mastering signal chain.
- 1972 Obfusc/ation — expanded track and remix creditsPink Floyd · Consulted 2026-11-15
Pages 1–2: all ten 2016 remixes, Andy Jackson, Damon Iddins, Pop Deux and ballet films. Official standalone-volume inventory. Its February-only recording range is narrower than the official chronology’s February/March account. Later remix jobs are separate from 1972 engineering.
Additional reading
Obscured by Clouds — official album page
Complete original track program and artist history.
Obscured by Clouds on Wikipedia
Secondary overview and bibliography.
La Vallée — producer’s film record
Film cast and technical credits.
Ginger Gilmour’s memoir
Book details and authorized excerpt.